Network switch is a crucial part of network infrastructure in today’s increasingly intricate and demanding network settings. Meanwhile, the market provides users with a wide range of switch brands and models to pick from. This article aims to compare the FS S5810-28TS and Aruba JL259A switches in order to help users understand their features and differences, enabling them to make a better product selection.
FS S5810-28TS vs. Aruba JL259A
Features
FS S5810-28TS is an aggregation switch that features 24x Gigabit RJ45 downlinks and 4x 1G/10G SFP+ uplinks, all of which support virtual stacking. It also supports Layer 3 features such as RIP, OSPF, VRRP, BGP, BFD, etc. Additionally, it offers non-stop upgrade, continuous forwarding, graceful restarting, and redundancy protection. On the other hand, the Aruba JL259A is an access switch that provides 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45 and 1 dual-personality (RJ-45 or USB micro-B) serial console port. It offers simplicity and scalability through stacking with the Virtual Switching Framework (VSF), supporting up to eight member VSF stacking. Overall, both switches have their unique strengths and are suitable for different network environments. The FS S5810-28TS excels in aggregation scenarios with its Layer 3 features and virtual stacking capabilities, while the Aruba JL259A is well-suited for access layer deployments with its simplicity and scalability through VSF stacking.
Performance
Performance is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a network switch, as it directly impacts the quality of hardware and the network experience. The FS S5810-28TS utilizes advanced Broadcom chips, enabling it to deliver impressive performance with a switching capacity of 136 Gbps and a forwarding rate of 102 Mpps. On the other hand, the Aruba JL259A uses the latest Aruba Provision ASIC design, which ensures low latency, increased packet buffering, and adaptive power consumption. The JL259A also offers selectable queue configurations, allowing users to optimize performance by selecting the appropriate number of queues and associated memory buffering to meet specific network application requirements. In terms of packet buffering, the Aruba JL259A has a larger packet buffer size compared to the FS S5810-28TS. A larger buffer size helps prevent packet loss and ensures smoother traffic flow by allowing for the storage of more packets. However, it’s important to note that larger buffers may lead to increased latency as packets are stored in the buffer for a longer period of time. It’s worth mentioning that the FS S5810-28TS boasts significantly higher switching capacity and forwarding rate compared to the Aruba JL259A. To strike a balance between buffer capacity and performance requirements, factors such as the network environment, traffic characteristics, and device resources should be taken into consideration.
Reliability
The stability of a gigabit switch is paramount for seamless network operation, and the power supply and fan system play a crucial role in ensuring its normal functioning. To ensure better stability, the FS S5810-28TS is equipped with redundant power supplies and fans. These redundant components automatically switch to backup power or fans in the event of a failure, preventing any interruptions caused by power or cooling issues. This redundant design provides enhanced reliability and stability. In contrast, the Aruba JL259A has an internal power supply and three fixed fans. While it doesn’t offer the same level of redundancy as the FS S5810-28TS, it does provide simple configuration for link redundancy with SmartLink. SmartLink allows for the configuration of active and standby links, ensuring continuous network connectivity in case of link failure. Although it may not have fully redundant power supplies and fans, the JL259A’s design offers inherent simplicity. Overall, both switches provide reliability for network operations, but the FS S5810-28TS offers more flexibility in terms of redundant design. It supports hot-swappable modules, which allows for easier replacement and maintenance of components without disrupting the network, resulting in enhanced stability and uptime.
Security
The security of a gigabit Ethernet switch is essential in protecting the network from unauthorized access and potential attacks. The FS S5810-28TS offers various security protocols such as SSH, ACL, AAA, 802.1X, RADIUS, and TACACS+. These protocols help secure the switch and authenticate users to prevent unauthorized access. Similarly, the Aruba JL259A also supports security protocols like ACL, RADIUS, and TACACS+, and it includes Control Plane Policing to set rate limits on control protocols. This feature protects the CPU from overload caused by denial-of-service attacks. Moreover, both switches feature dynamic ARP protection, which blocks ARP broadcasts from unauthorized hosts, ensuring network data is not at risk of eavesdropping or theft. In summary, both the FS S5810-28TS and Aruba JL259A offer robust security features and protocols to ensure the security of the network and its data.
Management
Switch management is an integral task to ensure the smooth operation of the switch and the network’s efficiency. It is crucial for building a reliable and high-performance network. The Gigabit Switch FS S5810-28TS supports various management options such as Airware Cloud, WEB, CLI, SNMP, and SSH for flexible operation. The Airware Cloud platform provided by FS allows for centralized management of branch networks. This centralized management improves efficiency, reduces costs, and ensures consistent network performance and security. Similarly, the Aruba JL259A offers the Aruba Central cloud-based management platform. This platform simplifies and secures switch management while also offering a cost-effective solution. Both switches provide centralized management platforms that are designed to enhance network configuration and management efficiency. These platforms ensure the proper operation and performance of the network while also offering improved security measures.
Warranty and Support
Warranty services primarily focus on hardware failures and the repair or replacement of defective hardware components. On the other hand, technical support mainly deals with software configuration, network failures, and usage issues. The 1G Switch FS S5810-28TS offers a 5-year limited warranty that covers defects in materials or workmanship. This warranty ensures that any hardware failures will be addressed and repaired or replaced as needed. Additionally, FS typically provides software updates free of charge, allowing customers to download the latest software versions to access new features and patches for existing issues. Moreover, each customer is assigned a dedicated account manager who can provide professional technical support at no extra cost. For Aruba, the warranty provided varies depending on the product. They offer limited lifetime warranties for some of their products, ensuring long-term coverage. The Aruba JL259A, for example, comes with a three-year warranty. Customers can refer to the Aruba website to find detailed information about software and software versions specific to their products. In short, both FS and Aruba offer warranty services to address hardware failures and provide technical support for software configuration, network issues, and usage problems.
Cost
The price of the network switch is indeed a significant factor in the customer’s decision-making process as it directly impacts their overall cost and budget. While it is true that the Gigabit switch FS S5810-28TS may be slightly more expensive than the Aruba JL259A switch, it is important to consider the superior features and capabilities offered by the FS S5810-28TS. In comparison to the Aruba JL259A switch, the FS S5810-28TS demonstrates advantages in areas such as switching capacity, forwarding rate, power supply, and fans. These factors contribute to the overall performance and reliability of the FS switch. Furthermore, Aruba is a reputable and well-known brand that provides warranty services, technical support, and other quality services. This can be a compelling factor for customers who prioritize brand reputation and reliable customer support. Ultimately, customers can make their decision based on their specific budget and requirements. It is essential to assess the features, capabilities, price, and brand reputation to ensure the chosen switch aligns with their needs and goals.Here is a table comparing the specifications of FS S5810-28TS and Aruba JL259A:
| Specification | FS S5810-28TS | Aruba JL259A |
| Ports | 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45, 4x 1G RJ45/SFP Combo | 4x 1G/10G SFP | 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45, Duplex: 10BASE-T/100BASE-TX: half or full; 1000BASE-T: full only 4 SFP |
| Switching Capacity | 136 Gbps | 56 Gbps |
| Forwarding Rate | 102 Mpps | 41.7 Mpps |
| Stacking | Up to 8 Units | Up to 8 Units |
| Power Supply | 2 (1+1 Redundancy) Hot-swappable | 1 Built-in |
| Fans | 3 (2+1 Redundancy) Built-in | 3 Built-in |
| Input Voltage | 100V-240V, 50-60Hz | 100-127/200-240 VAC, 50-60Hz |
| AC/DC Power Supply | AC | AC |
| Packet buffer size | 4MB | 12.38 MB |
| Cost | $1,249.00 | $958.00 |
Conclusion
The FS S5810-28TS offers operational stability with redundancy and a longer warranty period compared to the Aruba JL259A. It features 2 hot-swappable power supplies and 3 built-in fans. On the other hand, the Aruba JL259A provides more established brand support. It offers various technical support options and a comprehensive management suite, allowing for efficient management of the switch. To sum up, the decision between the FS S5810-28TS and the Aruba JL259A should be based on your specific needs and priorities. If you find it challenging to evaluate these factors, you can reach out to the customer service of both brands for further guidance. They will be able to advise you accordingly and address questions or concerns you may have.