When it comes to building a reliable and high-performance network, choosing the right gigabit switch is crucial. Among the numerous options available, two popular contenders stand out: FS S3100-16TF and Aruba JL075A. In this comparison guide, we’ll delve into the features and specifications of each switch to help you make an informed decision based on your networking needs.
FS S3100-16TF vs. Aruba JL075A
Performance and Features
FS S3100-16TF offers 16 Gigabit Ethernet ports, which support both IEEE 802.3af PoE and IEEE 802.3at PoE+ (up to 30W per port) for powering attached IP phones, wireless access points, or other standards-compliant PoE and PoE+ end network devices. This enterprise switch adopts a cutting-edge Broadcom chip to maintain working efficiency. On the other hand, the Aruba JL075A is also equipped with 16 Gigabit Ethernet ports, making it ideal for small to medium-sized networks. It supports the latest IEEE 802.3az Energy Efficient Ethernet (EEE) standard, enabling reduced power consumption during periods of low network activity. When it comes to forwarding rates, the FS S3100-16TF stands out with a remarkable rate of 23.8 Mpps. This capability enables swift data transmission and reduces latency, ensuring seamless communication within your network. On the other hand, the Aruba JL075A offers a comparable forwarding rate of about 285.7Mpps, providing efficient data transfer without compromising performance.
Scalability
When it comes to selecting a Gigabit Ethernet, scalability is a critical factor to consider since it’s an ability to scale up and downsize operations to accommodate the future and help businesses maximize their benefits. Both switches offer impressive scalability features to accommodate the growing needs of your network. FS S3100-16TF supports stacking technology, allowing you to combine multiple switches into a single logical unit. Similarly, the Aruba JL075A comes equipped with link aggregation capabilities, enabling you to bundle multiple physical ports into a high-bandwidth link.
Reliability and Redundancy
Reliability is paramount in any network infrastructure, and both switches offer robust mechanisms to ensure uninterrupted operation. The FS S3100-16TF incorporates a redundant power supply option, ensuring that your network stays powered even in the event of a power supply failure. Additionally, its smart fan design optimizes cooling, enhancing the switch’s overall longevity and performance. The Aruba JL075A also emphasizes reliability with its redundant power supply support, enabling uninterrupted operation in case of power source failure.
Management
Efficient network management is critical for maintaining optimal performance and security. The FS S3100-16TF offers multiple management options, including web-based management, making it user-friendly and accessible even to non-technical personnel. Additionally, it supports Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP) for centralized monitoring and SSH for secure remote access. Meanwhile, the Aruba JL075A offers a comprehensive command-line interface (CLI) for efficient configuration and monitoring. Moreover, the Aruba management platform enhances network visibility and control, allowing administrators to make informed decisions about network optimization.
Security
Security is a top priority in any network, and both switches deliver robust security features. The FS S3100-16TF supports SSH for secure remote access and Access Control Lists (ACL) for traffic filtering and control. It also offers RADIUS and TACACS+ authentication protocols to ensure secure user access to the network. Similarly, the Aruba JL075A provides enhanced security with support for SSH and ACL, enabling secure management and traffic control. Moreover, it offers CPU protection mechanisms to safeguard against denial-of-service (DoS) attacks, ensuring the stability and integrity of the switch.
Support & Warranty
Reliable support and warranty are concerns by customers since everyone hopes to receive timely responses and support when their products encounter issues. FS S3100-16TF enjoys 5 years limited warranty against defects in materials or workmanship. What’s more, FS provides a personal account manager, free professional technical support, and 24/5 live customer service for each customer. If you run into problems when installing or using your gigabit switch, you can get instant assistance from FS’s specialists. As for Aruba JL075A, it offers a limited lifetime product warranty varying from different products. You can also select the right level of support according to your specific demand to ensure business continuity. S5810-28TS and JL253A can both give you a satisfactory after-sale experience.
Cost
Price is one of the prioritized factors that many businesses would consider when choosing a switch. Comprehensively, FS offers more competitive pricing, making FS S3100-16TF an appealing choice for business organizations on a budget. It brings reliable products of high quality to customers at reasonable prices. However, Aruba JL075A tends to have a higher price partly because of its advanced features and brand reputation. Despite their difference in pricing, both switches deliver remarkable performance and satisfying experience, making them worthwhile for organizations.
Here is a table comparing the specifications of FS S3100-16TF and Aruba JL075A:
| Specification | FS S3100-16TF | Aruba JL075A |
| Ports | 16x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45, 2x 1Gb SFP | 16 SFP+ fixed 1000/10000 SFP+ ports |
| Switching Capacity | 36 Gbps | 508Gbps |
| Forwarding Rate | 26.8Mpps | 285.7Mpps |
| Power Supply | 1 Built-in | 2 Built-in |
| Fan | Fanless | 1 Built-in |
| AC/DC Power Supply | AC | AC |
| Cost | Varies (around US$300) | Varies (around US$5000) |
Conclusion
If you prioritize ports, redundancy, and a balance between performance and cost, FS S3100-16TF can be a suitable gigabit switch for you. It offers reliable performance and manifold features with optional after-sale service at a competitively low price. On the other hand, if you have a sufficient budget and require a higher switching capacity and forwarding rate, Aruba JL075A may suit you. To conclude, the decision between FS S3100-16TF and Aruba JL075A should be made based on your specific needs and priorities. Your final choice should be based on your specific networking requirements, budget constraints, and long-term growth plans. Whichever you choose, both switches are sure to elevate your network infrastructure and provide a solid foundation for seamless data communication and reliable connectivity.