In today’s increasingly complex and demanding networking environment, switches play an essential role as a crucial component of network infrastructure. At the same time, the market offers a variety of network switch brands and models for users to choose from. This article aims to compare the FS S5810-28TS and Aruba JL354A switches in order to help users understand their features and differences, assisting them in making a better product selection.
Feature
The FS S5810-28TS and Aruba JL354A are both equipped with excellent features to meet the networking needs of enterprises. FS S5810-28TS is a Gigabit Ethernet L3 Switch with 24x Gigabit RJ45, 4x Combo SFP ports, and 4x 10Gb SFP+ uplinks. It supports Layer 3 features such as RIP, OSPF, VRRP, BGP, etc, ensuring efficient routing and switching. It also supports for virtual local area networks (VLANs) and Quality of Service (QoS) features. Aruba JL354A is a 28-port lite Layer 3 fully managed, cloud-capable Gigabit access switch. This model has 24x Gigabit ports and 4x 10 Gigabit SFP+ ports for high speed connectivity. It also supports Quality of Service (QoS), VLAN, DHCP etc. Overall, they all have diverse ports to meet customers’ different port requirements and provide more complex and flexible network functionality.
Performance
The performance of a switch refers to its ability to process network traffic efficiently. Therefore, switch performance is one of the important factors for users to consider when choosing Gigabit switch products. FS S5810-28TS switch adopts cutting-edge Broadcom chips to deliver 136 Gbps switching capacity and 102 Mpps forwarding rate. Boasting advanced features such as enhanced Layer 3 functionality, simplified management, flexible IPv6 capabilities, and diverse multicast protocols, they are ideal for acting as an aggregation of large-scale campus networks and the core of small to medium-sized enterprise networks. Aruba JL354A switch has 128 Gbps switching capacity and 95.2 Mpps forwarding rate. Designed with the latest ProVision ASIC, it provides very low latency, increased packet buffering, and adaptive power consumption. In general, the performance of the FS S5810-28TS switch is slightly higher than that of the Aruba JL354A switch, with a higher switching capacity and forwarding rate. Additionally, FS S5810-28TS switch offers more advanced features, such as enhanced Layer 3 functionality and flexible IPv6 capabilities. However, Aruba JL354A switch also has its advantages, such as low latency and increased packet buffering. Users can choose a switch based on their own needs and budget.
Safety
在信息技术时代，用户更加关注网络的安全性。在安全性方面，FS S5810-28TS交换机支持802.1X网络认证，通过对设备进行认证来保证网络的安全性。它提供访问控制列表 （ACL） 用于对流量进行细粒度控制和过滤，从而保护网络免受未经授权的访问和攻击。它还支持DHCP Snooping，以检测和防止恶意DHCP服务器，确保网络上IP地址分配的安全性。该交换机提供 MAC 地址绑定和端口安全功能，以限制特定设备的访问并防止 MAC 和 ARP 欺骗攻击。Aruba JL354A 交换机提供多级访问控制和身份验证，支持 802.1X、MAC 身份验证和 WEB 身份验证方法。它提供动态 ARP 检测，以检测和防止窃听或窃取网络数据。它还支持动态 IP 锁定，它与 DHCP 保护配合使用，以阻止来自未经授权主机的流量，防止 IP 源地址欺骗。总体而言，FS S5810-28TS 和 Aruba JL354A 1G 交换机都提供了一系列功能来增强网络安全性。
Reliability
可靠性是开关连续运行的保证。FS S5810-28TS交换机是公认的高可靠换机之一。它采用优质的部件和材料，具有出色的容错性。交换机采用1+1冗余热插拔电源和2+1冗余内置风扇设计，即使在组件故障的情况下也能确保稳定运行。它还支持热插拔模块，方便维护和升级。Aruba JL354A 交换机还具有良好的可靠性。采用可靠的硬件设计和元器件选型，确保长期稳定运行。该开关具有高质量的冷却系统，可有效降低温度并延长设备寿命。它还具有严格的电源管理机制，以防止电压波动造成的损坏。总体而言，这两款千兆以太网交换机在可靠性方面都表现良好。它们都具有容错和强大的故障检测和恢复功能。然而，FS S5810-28TS交换机在冗余设计方面更加灵活，支持热插拔模块，为维护和升级提供了更方便的选择。Aruba JL354A 交换机在冷却和电源管理设计方面也表现出色。
Management and Monitoring
FS S5810-28TS交换机的管理和监控功能基于FSOS系统，支持Airware云管理，可实现对分支网络的统一管理，具有较高的灵活性和可扩展性。它还支持用于配置和管理的CLI和WEB接口，并提供SNMP协议以与其他管理系统集成。此外，它还支持RMON（远程监控）和sFlow等流量监控机制，以实时监控网络性能和流量分布。Aruba JL354A 交换机的管理和监控功能基于 ArubaOS-CX 系统，该系统还提供了广泛的管理选项。它支持CLI和WEB接口，可以通过SNMP等协议进行集成。Aruba JL354A 还提供 Intelligent Management Center 和 Aruba AirWave Network Management 等管理工具，可简化对多台交换机的集中管理和监控。此外，它还支持高级监控和报告功能，如RMON、XRMON、sFlow等。总之，虽然 FS S5810-28TS 交换机和 Aruba JL354A 交换机在管理和监控方面都提供了一系列功能，但 Aruba JL354A 交换机通过其生态系统和集中管理工具具有更多优势，尤其是对于大型和复杂的网络环境。
Warranty and Technical Support
The FS S5810-28TS switch usually provides a 5-year limited hardware warranty period. It also provides 24/5 technical support, and the technical support team can be contacted by phone, email, and live chat. In terms of software updates, the FS S5810-28TS switch is usually provided for free, and users can get new features and patches to fix existing problems by downloading the latest software version. While the Aruba JL354A switch usually provides a lifetime limited hardware warranty period. Due to the longer warranty period in Aruba, it is more advantageous for maintenance and troubleshooting. It provides 24/7 technical support, while Aruba also provides an extensive Knowledge Base and community forum where users can seek help and communicate with other users. The Aruba JL354A switch also provides free software updates, and Aruba usually releases regular updates to fix security bugs and improve performance. Overall, the Aruba JL354A switch has warranty and technical support advantages over the FS S5810-28TS switch, mainly reflected in the lifetime limited hardware warranty and extensive Knowledge Base and community forums.
成本
成本是用户选择产品的重要影响因素。1G FS S5810-28TS 交换机比 Aruba JL354A 交换机略贵。因为FS的交换机在容量、转换率、供电等方面都优于Aruba。Aruba 是一个相对高端的品牌，提供终身保修和技术支持等优质服务。总体来说，如果性能千兆交换机是您的首要考虑因素，那么FS将是您的最佳选择。如果您重视品牌影响力，那么 Aruba 也是一个不错的选择。
下表比较了 FS S5810-28TS 和 Aruba JL354A 的规格：
| Specification | FS S5810-28TS | Aruba JL354A |
| Ports | 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45, 4x 1G RJ45/SFP Combo | 4x 1G/10G SFP+ | 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45,4x 1G/10G SFP+ |
| Switching Capacity | 136 Gbps | 128 Gbps |
| Forwarding Rate | 102 Mpps | 95.2 Mpps |
| Power Supply | 2 (1+1 Redundancy) Hot-swappable | Internal power supply |
| Fan | 3 (2+1 Redundancy) Built-in | / |
| AC/DC Power Supply | AC | AC |
| Cost | Varies (around US$1,200) | Varies (around US$1100) |
Conclusion
综上所述，FS S5810-28TS 和 Aruba JL354A 交换机在不同方面各有优势。如果您更注重产品的性能和可靠性，那么FS S5810-28TS交换机是一个不错的选择。同时，FS可以根据不同的消费者需求定制不同的解决方案，将S5810-28TS与其他产品相结合，并提供专业的技术支持。另一方面，Aruba是一个知名品牌，在网络设备方面享有盛誉。它提供了丰富的管理功能，使网络管理更加灵活方便。在 FS S5810-28TS 和 Aruba JL354A 之间进行选择取决于用户的具体需求和预算。如果您重视额外的服务和支持，您可以选择 Aruba JL354A，而如果您对性能和可靠性更敏感，FS S5810-28TS 可能是更合适的选择。