Network protocols are a set of rules that govern how data is exchanged over a network. When it comes to RDMA, there are three main types: RDMA over Converged Ethernet (RoCE), InfiniBand, and Internet Wide Area RDMA Protocol (iWARP). This article will compare these three protocols, exploring what they are and which one is best suited for data centers.
What is RDMA?
Before delving into the details of the three RDMA protocols, let’s first take a look at what RDMA is and how it came about.
With the rapid advancement of technologies such as high-performance computing, big data analytics, and centralized and distributed storage solutions, there is an increasing demand in network environments for faster and more efficient data retrieval.
Traditional TCP/IP architectures and applications often encounter significant delays during network transmission and data processing. They also face challenges such as multiple data copies, interrupt handling, and the complexity of TCP/IP protocol management.
RDMA (Remote Direct Memory Access) was developed to address issues associated with server-side data processing during network transfers. It enables direct memory access between hosts or servers, bypassing the CPU. This capability allows the CPU to focus on running applications and managing large volumes of data, while network interface cards (NICs) handle data encapsulation, transmission, reception, and decapsulation.
traditional-vs-rdma
Overview of Three RDMA Protocols
Currently, there are roughly three types of RDMA networks: InfiniBand, RoCE, and iWARP. Among these, InfiniBand is a network designed specifically for RDMA, ensuring reliable transmission at the hardware level. RoCE and iWARP, on the other hand, are RDMA technologies based on Ethernet, supporting corresponding verbs interfaces.
- InfiniBand
InfiniBand excels with high throughput and minimal latency, ideal for interconnecting computers, servers, and storage systems. Unlike Ethernet-based RDMA protocols, InfiniBand relies on specialized adapters and switches, ensuring superior performance but at a higher cost due to dedicated hardware requirements.
- RoCE
RoCE, or RDMA over Converged Ethernet, meets modern network demands with efficient, scalable solutions. It integrates RDMA capabilities directly into Ethernet networks, offering two versions: RoCEv1 for Layer 2 deployments and RoCEv2, which enhances performance with UDP/IP integration for Layer 3 flexibility and compatibility.
- iWARP
iWARP enables RDMA over TCP/IP, suited for large-scale networks but requiring more memory resources than RoCE. Its connection-oriented approach supports reliable data transfer, but it may impose higher system specifications compared to InfiniBand and RoCE solutions.
Comparison Between Three RDMA Protocols
| Network Comparison | InfiniBand | RoCE | iWARP |
| Performance | Best | Equal to IB | Mediocre |
| Cost | Costly | Affordable | Cost-effective |
| Stability | Stable | Fairly Stable | Unstable |
| Switch | InfiniBand Switch | Ethernet Switch | Ethernet Switch |
| Ecosystem | Closed | Open | Open |
| RDMA Adaptability | Naturally Compatible | Additionally developed based on Ethernet | Additionally developed based on Ethernet |
From the table above, we can clearly see the differences among the three protocols and discern their strengths and weaknesses.
Today, data centers demand maximum bandwidth and minimal latency from their underlying interconnections. In this scenario, traditional TCP/IP network protocols fail to meet data center requirements due to increased CPU processing overhead and high latency, hence iWARP is now less commonly used.
For enterprises deciding between RoCE and InfiniBand, they should consider their specific requirements and costs. Those prioritizing the highest network performance may find InfiniBand preferable. Meanwhile, organizations seeking optimal performance, ease of management, and controlled costs should opt for RoCE in their data centers.
FS InfiniBand and RoCE Solutions
| Protocol | Type | Product |
| InfiniBand | Switches | NVIDIA® InfiniBand Switches |
| NICs | NVIDIA® InfiniBand Adapters | |
| Optical Modules | 800G NDR InfiniBand | |
| 400G NDR InfiniBand | ||
| 200G HDR InfiniBand | ||
| 100G EDR InfiniBand | ||
| 56/40G FDR InfiniBand | ||
| RoCE | Switches | NVIDIA® Ethernet Switches |
| NICs | NVIDIA® Ethernet Adapters | |
| Optical Modules | Ethernet Transceiver |
FS offers a range of products supporting both InfiniBand and RoCE protocols, providing customized solutions for various applications and user needs. These solutions optimize performance, offering high bandwidth, low latency, and seamless data transmission. Join us if you wanna optimize your network performance.
Conclusion
In conclusion, these three protocols have evolved to meet the increasing demands of data transmission over time. Enterprises can choose the protocol that best suits their needs. In this data-driven era, FS, along with other players in the ICT industry, looks forward to the emergence of new technological protocols in the future.